How EU ETS and FuelEU Maritime costs are calculated
A ship of 5 000 GT and above that trades to European ports now carries two separate regulatory costs on its fuel. The EU Emissions Trading System (ETS) requires the company to surrender one allowance for every tonne of CO₂, and from the 2026 reporting year every tonne of CO₂-equivalent, emitted on voyages in scope. FuelEU Maritime, which applies from 2025, sets a limit on the greenhouse-gas intensity of the energy used on board and charges a penalty when the ship's fuel is above it.
The two are easy to confuse because they share the same voyage scope and the same default emission factors. They measure different things, though, and they react differently to the same decision. This guide explains both, works one voyage through each to a cost in euros, scales it to a year, and lists the mistakes that most often spoil a budget. The EU ETS and FuelEU Maritime calculator reproduces every figure.
Two regimes, two different quantities
| EU ETS | FuelEU Maritime | |
|---|---|---|
| What it counts | Tonnes of CO₂ emitted (CH₄ and N₂O added as CO₂-equivalent from 2026) | Well-to-wake GHG intensity of the energy used, in gCO₂e/MJ |
| Boundary | Tank-to-wake: what leaves the funnel | Well-to-wake: production and transport of the fuel as well as combustion |
| Obligation | Surrender allowances, bought at the market price | Keep the yearly average intensity at or below a limit |
| Cost when you burn more fuel | Rises with every tonne | The intensity is unchanged for the same fuel mix; a deficit, and its penalty, scale with the energy |
| Greenhouse-gas weighting (GWP) | CH₄ 28, N₂O 265 | CH₄ 25, N₂O 298 |
| Legal basis | Directive (EU) 2023/959 amending Directive 2003/87/EC; MRV Regulation (EU) 2023/957 | Regulation (EU) 2023/1805 |
The practical difference: the ETS is a price on every tonne, so any fuel saving lowers it. FuelEU is a limit on an average. Burning less of the same fuel does not change the intensity, so it shrinks a deficit only in proportion to the energy. What moves FuelEU is the fuel itself, or a reward factor such as wind assistance.
Voyage scope: what counts and how much
Both regulations use the same scope:
- 100 % of the fuel burned on voyages between two EEA ports and while at berth in an EEA port;
- 50 % of the fuel burned on voyages between an EEA port and a port outside the EEA, in either direction;
- 0 % of everything else.
The fuel in scope is then:
scope factor = share_intra-EEA and at berth + 0.5 × share_EEA-to-non-EEA
Exemptions and special cases exist (transhipment ports, outermost regions, small islands, public-service routes and ice-class adjustments). They are not covered here.
EU ETS: emissions, phase-in and cost
For each fuel, CO₂-equivalent per gram of fuel is:
CO₂e per g = (1 − C_slip) × (Cf_CO2 + 28 × Cf_CH4 + 265 × Cf_N2O) + 28 × C_slip
(before 2026: (1 − C_slip) × Cf_CO2 only)
C_slip is the fraction of an LNG fuel that leaves the engine unburnt as methane; it is zero for oil fuels. Emissions in scope are the sum over fuels of mass × CO₂e per gram × scope factor. The allowances to surrender are those emissions times the phase-in share for the reporting year: 40 % for 2024, 70 % for 2025 and 100 % from 2026. They are surrendered by 30 September of the following year. The cost is allowances × the allowance (EUA) price. Shipping receives no free allocation, so every allowance is bought.
FuelEU: the intensity limit, compliance balance and penalty
Intensity of each fuel
Annex I of Regulation (EU) 2023/1805 gives the well-to-wake intensity of fuel i as the well-to-tank part plus the tank-to-wake part:
TtW_i = [(1 − C_slip)(Cf_CO2 + 25 × Cf_CH4 + 298 × Cf_N2O) + 25 × C_slip] ÷ LCV_i
WtW_i = WtT_i + TtW_i [gCO₂e/MJ]
The ship's attained intensity is the energy-weighted average over all fuel in scope, multiplied by the wind reward factor f_wind:
GHGIE = f_wind × Σ E_i × WtW_i ÷ Σ E_i, E_i = M_i × LCV_i × scope factor
The default factors of Annex II for the common fuels:
| Fuel | LCV, MJ/g | WtT, gCO₂e/MJ | Cf_CO2, g/g | Cf_CH4, g/g | Cf_N2O, g/g | WtW, gCO₂e/MJ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| HFO | 0.0405 | 13.5 | 3.114 | 0.00005 | 0.00018 | 91.74 |
| LFO / VLSFO | 0.041 | 13.2 | 3.151 | 0.00005 | 0.00018 | 91.39 |
| MGO / MDO | 0.0427 | 14.4 | 3.206 | 0.00005 | 0.00018 | 90.77 |
| LNG, Otto dual-fuel medium speed (slip 3.1 %) | 0.0491 | 18.5 | 2.75 | 0 | 0.00011 | 89.20 |
| LNG, Otto dual-fuel slow speed (slip 1.7 %) | 0.0491 | 18.5 | 2.75 | 0 | 0.00011 | 82.87 |
| LNG, lean-burn spark ignition (slip 2.6 %) | 0.0491 | 18.5 | 2.75 | 0 | 0.00011 | 86.94 |
| LNG, Diesel dual-fuel slow speed (slip 0.2 %) | 0.0491 | 18.5 | 2.75 | 0 | 0.00011 | 76.08 |
The LCV here is the regulation's default, not the value from the bunker analysis. The fuel specific energy and CO₂ factor calculator estimates the real LCV of a delivery from its density, water, ash and sulphur, which is useful for performance work but is not the figure FuelEU uses by default.
The limit
The limit is a reference value of 91.16 gCO₂e/MJ reduced in steps:
| From | 2025 | 2030 | 2035 | 2040 | 2045 | 2050 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Reduction | 2 % | 6 % | 14.5 % | 31 % | 62 % | 80 % |
| Limit, gCO₂e/MJ | 89.34 | 85.69 | 77.94 | 62.90 | 34.64 | 18.23 |
Every oil fuel in the table is already above the 2025 limit. A ship burning only HFO, VLSFO or MGO is in deficit from the first year.
Compliance balance and penalty
CB = (limit − GHGIE) × E_scope [gCO₂e]
penalty = |CB| ÷ (GHGIE × 41 000) × 2 400 EUR × (1 + (N − 1) ÷ 10) when CB < 0
A positive balance is a surplus; a negative one is a deficit. The penalty in Annex IV converts the deficit into the energy of fuel that would have been needed to close it, expressed in tonnes of VLSFO-equivalent at 41 000 MJ per tonne, and charges 2 400 EUR for each. N is the number of consecutive years with a deficit, so the second year in a row costs 1.1 times the formula value and the third 1.2 times.
A surplus can be banked to the next year or pooled with other ships. A deficit can be pooled against a surplus, or borrowed against the next year: up to 2 % of the limit times the energy, repaid with a 10 % premium.
Worked example: one inbound voyage and port stay in 2026
A ship sails from a port outside the EEA to an EEA port and burns 600 t of VLSFO at sea. It then spends its port stay at berth burning 40 t of MGO. The reporting year is 2026, it is the first deficit year, there is no wind assistance, and the allowance price is taken as 75 EUR per tonne, a budget assumption, not a forecast.
- Scope. The sea passage is EEA to non-EEA, so 50 % counts: 300 t of VLSFO. The berth fuel counts 100 %: 40 t of MGO.
- Energy in scope. VLSFO 600 × 10⁶ g × 0.041 MJ/g × 0.5 = 12.300 TJ; MGO 40 × 10⁶ × 0.0427 = 1.708 TJ; total 14.008 TJ.
- Fuel intensities. VLSFO: 13.2 + (3.151 + 25 × 0.00005 + 298 × 0.00018) ÷ 0.041 = 13.2 + 3.20589 ÷ 0.041 = 91.39 gCO₂e/MJ. MGO: 14.4 + 3.26089 ÷ 0.0427 = 90.77.
- Attained intensity. (12.300 × 91.39 + 1.708 × 90.77) ÷ 14.008 = 91.32 gCO₂e/MJ, against the 2026 limit of 91.16 × 0.98 = 89.34: 2.2 % over.
- Compliance balance. (89.34 − 91.32) × 14.008 × 10⁶ MJ = −27.73 × 10⁶ g, a deficit of 27.73 t CO₂e.
- FuelEU penalty. 27.73 × 10⁶ ÷ (91.32 × 41 000) = 7.41 t VLSFO-equivalent; × 2 400 = 17 774 EUR.
- ETS emissions. CO₂e per gram from 2026: VLSFO 3.151 + 28 × 0.00005 + 265 × 0.00018 = 3.2001; MGO 3.2551. Emissions in scope 300 × 3.2001 + 40 × 3.2551 = 960.03 + 130.20 = 1 090.23 t CO₂e.
- ETS cost. 100 % phase-in in 2026: 1 090.23 allowances × 75 = 81 768 EUR.
- Together 99 542 EUR for the voyage and port stay: 293 EUR per tonne of fuel in scope, or 155.5 EUR per tonne of all 640 t burned, on top of the fuel price.
The calculator applies one voyage split to all the fuels you enter, so for this voyage enter fuel 1 as VLSFO 300 t and fuel 2 as MGO 40 t with 100 % in the first share (the in-scope masses), year 2026 and EUA 75. Because both quantities are linear in mass and scope, entering 300 t at 100 % is the same as entering 600 t at 50 %. The calculator then returns the intensity, balance, penalty and ETS figures above. To size the fuel itself, the fuel consumption and voyage cost calculator gives the tonnes for a passage from distance, speed and daily consumption.
The same voyage in other years
| Reporting year | Limit | FuelEU penalty | ETS allowances | ETS cost at 75 EUR |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2025 | 89.34 | 17 774 EUR | 751.5 (70 % of 1 073.5 t CO₂) | 56 361 EUR |
| 2026 | 89.34 | 17 774 EUR | 1 090.2 (100 %, CO₂e) | 81 768 EUR |
| 2030 | 85.69 | 50 518 EUR | 1 090.2 | 81 768 EUR |
| 2035 | 77.94 | 120 097 EUR | 1 090.2 | 81 768 EUR |
Two things move between 2025 and 2026: the phase-in steps from 70 % to 100 %, and CH₄ and N₂O join the ETS, adding 16.7 t CO₂e to this voyage. After 2026 the ETS stays flat for the same fuel and price, while the FuelEU penalty grows with each step of the limit. By 2035 it is larger than the ETS cost.
Scaling to a year
FuelEU is settled on the year's total, not voyage by voyage, so the yearly balance is what you budget. Take a ship that burns 5 000 t of VLSFO and 400 t of MGO in 2026, with 30 % of the fuel on intra-EEA voyages and at berth and 50 % on voyages to or from non-EEA ports (scope factor 0.55). At 75 EUR per allowance the calculator gives:
- attained intensity 91.34 gCO₂e/MJ, a deficit of 245 t CO₂e and a FuelEU penalty of 157 141 EUR (172 855 EUR if it is the second consecutive deficit year);
- ETS emissions of 9 516 t CO₂e and 713 730 EUR of allowances;
- 870 870 EUR in total, about 293 EUR per tonne of fuel in scope.
A useful rule of thumb from the same numbers: for an oil-fuelled ship the FuelEU penalty works out at about 641 EUR per tonne of CO₂e of deficit (2 400 × 10⁶ ÷ (91.34 × 41 000)), many times the allowance price assumed here.
What a fuel change does
Replace the VLSFO with LNG carrying the same energy: 4 175 t, from the alternative fuel tank calculator, which also shows that it needs 1.9 times the volume of the VLSFO (taken at 960 kg/m³). In a Diesel-cycle slow-speed engine (slip 0.2 %) the attained intensity falls to 77.21 gCO₂e/MJ, a surplus of 1 481 t CO₂e to bank or pool, and the ETS falls to 7 214 t (541 018 EUR). In an Otto-cycle medium-speed engine (slip 3.1 %) the same LNG gives 89.32 against the 89.34 limit, a surplus of only 1.7 t, and the ETS is 8 893 t. Methane slip decides whether LNG solves FuelEU at all.
Wind assistance
The reward factor f_wind multiplies the attained intensity: 0.99 when the wind propulsion power is 5 to 10 % of the propulsion power, 0.97 for 10 to 15 %, and 0.95 at 15 % and above. On the example voyage f_wind = 0.97 lowers the intensity to 88.58 and turns the deficit into a 10.6 t surplus, while the ETS cost is unchanged unless the wind actually saves fuel. The rotor sail calculator estimates the thrust power a rotor delivers, which is the starting point for that ratio.
Who pays under a charter
Both regulations place the legal obligation on the shipping company responsible for the ship, which is usually the registered owner or the ISM manager, not the charterer. Commercially, the cost follows whoever controls the fuel and the ship's employment, and that is settled by contract:
- Time charter. The charterer buys the fuel and chooses the trade, so the usual arrangement is that the charterer transfers allowances (or pays for them) for the emissions of its voyages, and the FuelEU deficit or surplus is passed through in the same way. BIMCO has published standard clauses for both.
- Voyage charter. The owner buys the fuel, so the owner bears both costs and recovers them through the freight or a surcharge.
- Pooling and surpluses. A FuelEU surplus has value. Who owns it, the owner whose ship earned it or the charterer whose fuel choice created it, needs to be written into the charter party. Leaving it open is a common source of dispute.
None of this changes the arithmetic, but it decides whose budget the numbers belong in.
Common mistakes
- Counting the whole inbound voyage. A voyage from a non-EEA port counts at 50 %. Counting all 600 t of the example's VLSFO at 100 % doubles the sea-passage part: 153 770 EUR of allowances for the voyage instead of 81 768.
- Forgetting the berth fuel. Fuel burned at berth in an EEA port counts at 100 %, and on short-sea trades it can be a large share of the total.
- Using the 2025 phase-in for 2026. The share goes from 70 % to 100 %, and CH₄ and N₂O join the ETS in the same year.
- Mixing the GWPs. FuelEU uses 25 and 298, the ETS 28 and 265. Applying one set to both gives the wrong number for one of them, and the difference is largest for LNG.
- Tank-to-wake intensity in FuelEU. The limit is well-to-wake. VLSFO at 77.0 g CO₂/MJ tank-to-wake (the combustion CO₂ alone) looks comfortably under 89.34 until the CH₄, N₂O and the 13.2 gCO₂e/MJ well-to-tank share are added.
- Mass-weighted averages. The FuelEU average is weighted by energy, mass × LCV, not by mass.
- Treating the penalty as a price per tonne of CO₂. It is a price per tonne of VLSFO-equivalent energy, and it rises by 10 % for each consecutive deficit year.
- Assuming the CII rating says anything about FuelEU. The CII divides CO₂ by capacity and distance; FuelEU divides well-to-wake CO₂e by energy. Slow steaming improves the CII and lowers the ETS cost but does nothing to the FuelEU intensity. See the CII guide and the CII rating estimator.
Limits of the method
The method above uses the Annex II default factors for fossil fuels. LPG and fossil methanol have no default CH₄ and N₂O factors yet ("to be measured") and are taken as zero, which slightly understates their intensity. Biofuels, RFNBOs (which carry a reward factor of 2 until 2033), onshore power supply and the 2 % RFNBO sub-target from 2034 are outside it, as is the arithmetic of banking and borrowing. Certified actual methane slip may replace the default for an LNG engine. The voyage split is an estimate unless it comes from the MRV monitoring data.
On the ETS side, the cost shown is allowances × price with no hedging and no administrative cost. Failing to surrender attracts a penalty of 100 EUR per tonne, on top of still having to surrender the allowances.
The governing texts are Regulation (EU) 2023/1805 (FuelEU Maritime, with Annex I for the intensity formula, Annex II for the default factors and Annex IV for the penalty), Directive (EU) 2023/959 and the MRV Regulation (EU) 2023/957 for the ETS, and the European Commission's guidance on the FuelEU Maritime Regulation for shipping companies.
Calculators used in this guide
- MaritimeEU ETS and FuelEU MaritimeEU ETS allowances and cost with phase-in and voyage scope; FuelEU Maritime GHG intensity against the yearly limit, compliance balance and penalty.
- MaritimeFuel net specific energy and CO₂ factorISO 8217 net and gross specific energy from density, water, ash and sulphur; CO₂ factor by IMO grade or carbon content; g CO₂/MJ.
- MaritimeFuel consumption and voyage costFuel burned, time at sea, bunker cost and CO₂ for a passage from distance, speed and engine power or daily consumption.
- MaritimeAlternative fuel tank volumeMass, volume and tank capacity of LNG, methanol, ammonia, hydrogen, LPG or biofuels carrying the same energy as a quantity of oil fuel.
- MaritimeCII rating estimatorAttained and required operational CII with the A–E rating, from ship type, capacity, annual fuel or CO₂ and distance.
- MaritimeRotor sail (Flettner rotor) thrust and savingThrust, side force, spin power and net power saving of Flettner rotors from the true wind and ship speed, at the best spin, and averaged over a wind table.
Results are estimates. They do not replace the governing code, class or flag requirements, or a check by a competent person. Report an error in this guide
More guides
- Cargo securing calculation to CSS Code Annex 13
- How to do a draft survey calculation, step by step
- How to calculate a ship's CII rating, step by step
- Hull and propeller performance in service with ISO 19030
- Ship resistance and powering: from hull to installed power
- How to calculate ship squat and under-keel clearance