Skip to content
Engineering Bible

Results appear as you type. Use the arrow keys to move through them and Enter to open one.

Popular

↑ ↓ moveEnter openEsc close

Maritime guide

Cargo securing calculation to CSS Code Annex 13

By Christos Papandreou. Updated . About 13 minutes to read.

A transformer, a yacht on a cradle, a press frame or a stack of steel structures has no standard securing system. Containers have cell guides and twistlocks, and the Cargo Securing Manual has a page for them. A one-off unit only has whatever the crew or the stevedores weld, chain and wire to the deck. Whether that arrangement will hold in a winter gale is a calculation, and Annex 13 of the IMO Code of Safe Practice for Cargo Stowage and Securing (the CSS Code) says how to do it.

The method is short enough to do by hand on the back of a stowage plan. Take a design acceleration for the stowage position. Correct it for the ship's length, speed and stiffness. Turn it into forces, adding wind and sea sloshing for deck cargo. Then show that friction and lashings together resist those forces without the unit sliding or tipping. This guide works through each step with the Code's tables, gives a complete example for one unit, and lists the errors that make a calculation that passes on paper fail at sea.

What Annex 13 is for

Annex 13, "Methods to assess the efficiency of securing arrangements for non-standardized cargo" (MSC/Circ.664, as amended), is for cargo units that are not covered by a standardised securing system: heavy machinery, project cargo, vehicles and boats, steel structures, anything without a pre-approved arrangement in the Cargo Securing Manual. Containers on containerships and other standardised cargo follow their own rules (Annex 14 and the Cargo Securing Manual), not this method. The guidance for preparing the manual itself is MSC.1/Circ.1353/Rev.2.

The annex gives two levels of check. The rule of thumb is a quick sum of lashing strengths against the unit's weight. The advanced calculation method uses design accelerations and balances forces and moments. The cargo securing calculator does both, and it is the advanced method that decides.

MSL, breaking load and calculated strength

Every securing device has a maximum securing load (MSL): the load it may carry in service. The MSL is derived from the breaking load by a percentage that depends on the kind of device. The Code's Table 1 includes, for example:

DeviceMSL as a share of breaking strength
Shackles, rings, deck eyes, turnbuckles (mild steel)50 %
Wire rope, single use80 %
Wire rope, re-usable30 %
Chains50 %

Take the actual figures from the ship's Cargo Securing Manual. A lashing is a chain of components (deck eye, shackle, turnbuckle, wire or chain, shackle, lashing point on the cargo), and its MSL is the smallest MSL of any component in it. A 200 kN chain with a 50 % MSL gives 100 kN, but if the deck eye it hangs from is rated lower, the lashing is rated at the deck eye.

The breaking load of the rope or chain comes from the certificate. Without one, the wire rope and chain calculator gives the EN 12385-4 minimum breaking load: 161 kN for a 16 mm 6×36 steel-core rope of grade 1770. As a re-usable lashing (30 %) that rope has an MSL of 48 kN; used once and discarded (80 %), 129 kN. The same rope is worth almost three times as much on paper depending on how it is used, which is why the Code distinguishes them.

In the balance calculation each lashing counts not with its MSL but with its calculated strength:

CS = MSL ÷ 1.5

The factor 1.5 allows for the fact that lashings never share a load evenly and assembly is never perfect.

Design accelerations and their corrections

Table 2 of the annex gives basic accelerations for a ship of 100 m at 15 knots with B/GM of 13 or more, in unrestricted service all year on a 25-day voyage. They depend on where the unit is stowed: on deck high, on deck low, in the tween deck or in the lower hold, and its position along the ship, as x/L measured from aft. The transverse figures include the component of gravity from the roll angle.

x/L from aft0.10.20.30.40.50.60.70.80.9
a_y on deck, high7.16.96.86.76.76.86.97.17.4
a_y on deck, low6.56.36.16.16.16.16.36.56.7
a_y tween deck5.95.65.55.45.45.55.65.96.2
a_y lower hold5.55.35.15.05.05.15.35.55.9
a_z (all levels)7.66.25.04.34.35.06.27.69.2

All values are in m/s². The longitudinal acceleration a_x does not vary along the ship: 3.8 on deck high, 2.9 on deck low, 2.0 in the tween deck and 1.5 in the lower hold. Between stations the calculator interpolates linearly, and it holds the end values forward of 0.9 and aft of 0.1. The pattern is what you would expect: the accelerations are smallest amidships and low down, and largest high up and at the bow.

Length and speed (Table 3). All three accelerations are multiplied by a factor that falls with length and rises with speed. A few entries:

Speed50 m100 m120 m140 m160 m200 m
9 kn1.200.790.700.630.570.49
15 kn1.491.000.890.800.730.63
18 kn1.641.100.980.890.820.71
24 kn1.931.311.171.070.980.85

The calculator interpolates in both directions. Outside the table (50 to 200 m, 9 to 24 knots) it uses the nearest value and warns. A small, fast ship has much larger accelerations than the 100 m reference: a 50 m coaster at 15 knots takes 1.49 times the basic figures.

Stiffness (Table 4). A ship with a large GM rolls quickly and violently. For B/GM below 13 the transverse acceleration alone is multiplied by a further factor:

B/GM78910111213 or more
On deck, high1.561.401.271.191.111.051.00
On deck, low1.421.301.211.141.091.041.00
Tween deck1.261.191.141.091.061.031.00
Lower hold1.151.121.091.061.041.021.00

Below B/GM = 7 the calculator holds the factor at 7 and warns that the real accelerations may be higher still. The GM to use is the one for the departure condition, corrected for free surface; the initial stability calculator gives it from KM, KG and the free-surface moments.

External forces: inertia, wind and sloshing

The forces on the unit are its mass times the corrected accelerations, plus wind and sea sloshing for cargo on deck:

F_x = m × a_x + F_wind,x + F_slosh,x
F_y = m × a_y + F_wind,y + F_slosh,y
F_z = m × a_z

With m in tonnes and a in m/s², m × a comes out in kN directly. Wind is taken as 1 kN/m² on the exposed area: the side (length × height) for the transverse force, the front (breadth × height) for the longitudinal one. Sea sloshing is another 1 kN/m² on the same faces, but only up to 2 m above the deck. Neither applies below deck. Sloshing may be neglected in restricted service areas; the calculator always applies the wind term. The figures are fixed by the Code and do not change with the forecast, so a Beaufort number from the Beaufort scale converter does not enter the calculation. Its use is in deciding whether the voyage really is in a restricted area and sheltered water.

The vertical force is not resisted by lashings in the Code's method. It is used only to reduce the normal force, and therefore the friction, in the longitudinal balance.

Friction coefficients

The Code allows friction between the unit and the stowage surface to resist sliding. The coefficients are low and the differences between them are large:

Contactμ
Steel on timber, or steel on rubber0.3
Steel on steel, dry0.1
Steel on steel, wet0.0

Timber dunnage or rubber mats triple the friction of a dry steel deck. On wet steel every newton must be taken by the lashings.

The sliding and tipping balances

Each lashing contributes to the sliding balance by its calculated strength multiplied by an efficiency factor f, which depends on its vertical angle α to the deck:

f = μ × sin α + cos α

The cosine is the horizontal pull. The sine term is the extra friction from the lashing pressing the unit down. With μ = 0.3, f is 1.00 at 0°, 1.04 at 10° to 20°, 1.02 at 30°, 0.96 at 40°, 0.87 at 50° and 0.76 at 60°. Lashings steeper than 60° are not counted against sliding, and neither are those that deviate more than 30° from the transverse direction.

Transverse sliding. For a force to port, the lashings on the starboard side hold the unit, and vice versa:

F_y ≤ μ × m × g + Σ CS × f

Transverse tipping. Take moments about the edge the unit would tip over. a is the height of the centre of gravity above that edge, b the horizontal distance from the centre of gravity to the edge (the lever of stableness), and c the lever of each lashing about the edge:

F_y × a ≤ b × m × g + Σ CS × c

Longitudinal sliding. The vertical acceleration lifts the unit and reduces the friction:

F_x ≤ μ × (m × g − F_z) + Σ CS × f

Here the lashings are the ones leading forward or aft. Transverse lashings usually have some longitudinal component as well, and the Code lets you count it, but at no more than 0.5 CS each.

The Code uses g = 9.81 m/s². The calculator runs all six balances (sliding and tipping to each side, sliding forward and aft) and reports any that fail.

Worked example: a 40 t unit on deck

A 40 t machinery skid, 5 m long, 3 m wide and 3.5 m high, stands on timber dunnage (μ = 0.3) low on deck at 0.8 L of a 140 m general cargo ship with a service speed of 16 knots, a breadth of 22 m and a GM of 2.2 m, in unrestricted service. Its centre of gravity is 1.8 m above the tipping edge and 1.5 m inboard of it. It is secured with chain lashings of MSL 100 kN: four on each side at 35° with a lever of 2.6 m about the tipping edge, and two forward and two aft at 30°.

  1. Corrections. Table 3 at 140 m gives 0.80 at 15 knots and 0.89 at 18 knots; at 16 knots, 0.80 + 0.09 × 1/3 = 0.83. B/GM = 22 ÷ 2.2 = 10, so Table 4 (on deck, low) gives 1.14.
  2. Accelerations. At x/L = 0.8, on deck low: a_x = 2.9 × 0.83 = 2.41 m/s²; a_y = 6.5 × 0.83 × 1.14 = 6.15 m/s²; a_z = 7.6 × 0.83 = 6.31 m/s².
  3. Wind and sloshing. Transverse: wind on 5 × 3.5 = 17.5 m², 17.5 kN; sloshing on 5 × 2 = 10 m², 10 kN. Longitudinal: wind 3 × 3.5 = 10.5 kN, sloshing 3 × 2 = 6 kN.
  4. Forces. F_x = 40 × 2.407 + 10.5 + 6 = 112.8 kN. F_y = 40 × 6.150 + 17.5 + 10 = 273.5 kN. F_z = 40 × 6.308 = 252.3 kN.
  5. Lashings. CS = 100 ÷ 1.5 = 66.7 kN. f at 35° = 0.3 × 0.574 + 0.819 = 0.991; at 30°, 1.016. Weight m g = 40 × 9.81 = 392.4 kN.
  6. Transverse sliding. 0.3 × 392.4 + 4 × 66.7 × 0.991 = 117.7 + 264.3 = 382.0 kN ≥ 273.5 kN. OK, the same to each side.
  7. Transverse tipping. Tipping moment 273.5 × 1.8 = 492.3 kN·m. Resisting: 1.5 × 392.4 + 4 × 66.7 × 2.6 = 588.6 + 693.3 = 1,281.9 kN·m. OK.
  8. Longitudinal sliding. Friction 0.3 × (392.4 − 252.3) = 42.0 kN; lashings 2 × 66.7 × 1.016 = 135.5 kN; total 177.5 kN ≥ 112.8 kN. OK.
  9. Rule of thumb. Σ MSL on each side 4 × 100 = 400 kN ≥ 392.4 kN. OK, just.

The arrangement passes all six balances, with about 40 % in hand on transverse sliding. Now take away the dunnage and stand the skid on dry steel (μ = 0.1). Friction drops to 39.2 kN, f at 35° falls to 0.877, and the resistance to sliding becomes 39.2 + 233.7 = 273.0 kN, 0.5 kN short of the 273.5 kN load. The unit now fails transverse sliding to both sides. The forces have not changed and the lashings have not changed, only the surface under the unit.

The cargo securing calculator reproduces every figure above, and with its default inputs it reproduces the Code's own worked example: a 62 t unit on a 120 m ship, F_y = 384 kN against 412 kN from the starboard lashings and 422 kN from the port ones.

Rule of thumb against the advanced calculation

The rule of thumb asks only that the MSL of the lashings on each side add up to at least the weight of the unit in kN. That is the same as asking them to resist a sideways acceleration of 1 g. It is quick and needs no tables, but it ignores lashing angles, friction, the stowage position, and the ship's size, speed and stiffness. In the example it passed by 2 % while the advanced method showed 40 % in hand. Move the same unit to a 50 m coaster at 15 knots and the advanced method would give it far larger accelerations, while the rule of thumb would not change at all. Use the rule of thumb to see quickly whether an arrangement is in the right range. Use the advanced method to decide.

Common mistakes

Limits of the method

The accelerations in Table 2 are design values for unrestricted service all year, not maxima. The annex warns that they may be exceeded in marked roll resonance with amplitudes over 30°, when running before large stern or quartering seas with marginal stability, and with slamming in head seas. The Code expects the master to avoid these by course and speed, and the securing calculation assumes that he does.

The method is quasi-static. It does not model the elastic sharing of load between lashings, the strength of the cargo's own lashing points or of the deck structure beneath the eyes, or the shifting of a unit whose own contents can move. Units on containerships and standardised cargo fall under their own rules. The CTU Code (IMO/ILO/UNECE Code of Practice for Packing of Cargo Transport Units), Annex 7, uses the same friction and securing principles for cargo inside a container or a trailer. Whatever the calculation shows, the securing must be inspected and re-tightened during the voyage: a lashing that has gone slack after the first night of rolling has a strength of zero until somebody tightens it again.

Calculators used in this guide

Results are estimates. They do not replace the governing code, class or flag requirements, or a check by a competent person. Report an error in this guide

By Christos Papandreou. How the numbers are checked.