Skip to content
Engineering Bible

Results appear as you type. Use the arrow keys to move through them and Enter to open one.

Popular

↑ ↓ moveEnter openEsc close

Heat pump vs gas boiler running cost calculator

Heat pump running cost and CO₂ against a gas or oil boiler from the yearly heat demand, SCOP, boiler efficiency and prices, with the saving and break-even COP.

Units

Results are estimates. They do not replace the governing code, class or flag requirements, or a check by a competent person. Report a problem

Introduction

Is a heat pump cheaper to run than a gas boiler? It depends on two ratios. The heat pump turns each kWh of electricity into SCOP kWh of heat, while the boiler turns each kWh of gas into about 0.9 kWh of heat. With electricity at 0.20 and gas at 0.07 per kWh, a heat pump with an SCOP of 3.2 saves about 20 % on a 12 000 kWh heating bill.

This calculator compares the yearly running cost and CO₂ of a heat pump and a gas or oil boiler for the same heat demand. It gives the saving and the break-even COP, the seasonal COP at which both cost the same. Gas and oil prices can be entered per kWh, therm, ccf, gallon or litre. It is for homeowners, installers and energy advisers.

Formulas

Energy and cost for the same heat Q:

E_hp = Q / SCOP,          cost_hp = E_hp × p_elec
E_fuel = Q / η,           cost_boiler = E_fuel × p_fuel
saving = cost_boiler − cost_hp

Break-even COP for cost and for CO₂:

COP_cost = p_elec × η / p_fuel
COP_CO₂ = f_elec × η / f_fuel
  • Q — heat needed per year for space heating and hot water
  • SCOP — seasonal coefficient of performance of the heat pump
  • η — seasonal efficiency of the boiler, gross basis
  • p_elec, p_fuel — prices per kWh of electricity and of fuel
  • f_elec, f_fuel — CO₂ per kWh of electricity and of fuel

Fuel units, EPA heat contents:

1 therm = 100 000 Btu = 29.31 kWh
1 ccf of natural gas = 102 600 Btu = 30.07 kWh
1 US gal of No. 2 heating oil = 138 000 Btu = 40.44 kWh

Assumptions and limitations

  • The SCOP must suit your climate and flow temperature. A heat pump feeding radiators at 55 °C has a lower SCOP than one feeding underfloor heating at 35 °C.
  • Boiler efficiency and fuel energy are both on the gross basis, like US AFUE ratings and UK SEDBUK figures.
  • The CO₂ factors are examples. Gas and oil use the EPA factors of 0.181 and 0.252 kg per kWh. The electricity factor depends on your grid and changes every year.
  • Standing charges, servicing and time-of-use tariffs are not included. Dropping the gas connection removes its standing charge too.

Worked example

A house needs 12 000 kWh of heat a year. The gas boiler is 90 % efficient and gas costs 0.07 per kWh. A heat pump with an SCOP of 3.2 would run on electricity at 0.20 per kWh. Which is cheaper?

  1. Heat pump electricity: 12 000 / 3.2 = 3 750 kWh, costing 3 750 × 0.20 = 750.00.
  2. Boiler gas: 12 000 / 0.90 = 13 333 kWh, costing 13 333 × 0.07 = 933.33.
  3. Saving with the heat pump: 933.33 − 750.00 = 183.33 a year.
  4. Break-even COP: 0.20 × 0.90 / 0.07 = 2.57. Any SCOP above this saves money.

With an electricity factor of 0.25 kg per kWh, the heat pump emits 938 kg of CO₂ a year. The boiler emits 13 333 × 0.181 = 2 413 kg.

FAQ

Is a heat pump cheaper to run than a gas boiler?

Yes, when its SCOP is above the break-even COP, the electricity price times the boiler efficiency divided by the gas price. At 0.20 and 0.07 per kWh that is 2.57.

What is SCOP?

The seasonal coefficient of performance: the heat delivered over a year divided by the electricity used, under the conditions of EN 14825.

What COP does a heat pump need to beat gas?

It depends on the price ratio. At 0.25 for electricity and 0.07 for gas with a 90 % boiler, it needs 3.21.

How do I convert a gas price per therm to per kWh?

Divide by 29.31. A price of 1.50 per therm is 0.0512 per kWh.

How do I convert a heating oil price per gallon to per kWh?

Divide by 40.44 for No. 2 heating oil. At 3.50 per gallon that is 0.0865 per kWh.

Does a heat pump always cut CO₂?

It does when its SCOP is above the break-even COP for CO₂. With a 90 % gas boiler, gas at 0.181 kg and electricity at 0.25 kg per kWh, that is only 1.24.

Related calculators

What this calculator is checked against

Before every release the calculator must reproduce each case below. The note under each case says where the expected answer comes from: a standard, a textbook, a published table, or a hand calculation shown in full.

  1. 12 000 kWh at SCOP 3.2 and 0.20/kWh: 3 750 kWh, 750.00; 90 % gas boiler at 0.07/kWh: 13 333 kWh, 933.33; saving 183.33; break-even COP 2.571Hand calculation: E = Q / SCOP, E = Q / η, COP_be = p_e η / p_f
  2. EPA heat contents: a therm is 29.307 kWh, a ccf of gas 30.07 kWh, a US gallon of No. 2 oil 40.44 kWh, a litre 10.68 kWhEPA GHG Emission Factors Hub Table 1 (1 026 Btu/scf, 0.138 MMBtu/gal); 1 therm = 100 000 Btu; 1 Btu = 1 055.05585262 J
  3. EPA CO₂ factors: natural gas 53.06 kg/MMBtu = 0.1810 kg/kWh, No. 2 oil 73.96 kg/MMBtu = 0.2524 kg/kWhEPA GHG Emission Factors Hub Table 1; 1 MMBtu = 293.071 kWh
  4. At the break-even COP the heat pump and the boiler cost the same; above it the heat pump is cheaperDefinition of the break-even COP
  5. Oil at 3.50 per US gallon in an 85 % boiler: 14 118 kWh, 349.1 gal, 1 221.74 a yearHand calculation with 40.444 kWh per gallon (EPA)
  6. A zero electricity price, an SCOP below 1 and an unknown fuel are rejectedBehaviour check: warnings and rejected inputs
  7. Worked example of the article: the calculator reproduces 3 750 kWh, 750.00, 13 333 kWh, 933.33, 183.33, 2.57, 2 413 kg to the digits printedThe worked example on this page, to the digits printed

Assumptions and sources

Assumptions and limits

  • Both systems deliver the same yearly heat to the home. The heat pump uses heat / SCOP of electricity, where the SCOP is the seasonal coefficient of performance for the climate and flow temperature (EN 14825); the boiler uses heat / efficiency of fuel.
  • Fuel energy and boiler efficiency are both on the gross (higher heating value) basis, as US AFUE ratings and UK SEDBUK figures are. Gas and oil price units convert with the EPA heat contents: 1 026 Btu per cubic foot of natural gas and 138 000 Btu per US gallon of No. 2 heating oil; a therm is 100 000 Btu.
  • Default CO₂ factors are examples: natural gas 0.181 and heating oil 0.252 kg CO₂ per kWh of fuel from the EPA factors (53.06 and 73.96 kg per MMBtu); the electricity factor depends on the grid and the year, so enter your supplier's or country's figure.
  • Standing charges, maintenance, boiler servicing, time-of-use tariffs and the electricity a boiler's pump and fan use are not included; a gas standing charge you no longer pay after removing the boiler adds to the heat pump's saving.
  • The break-even COP is the seasonal COP at which the two running costs are equal; a heat pump with a higher SCOP is cheaper to run.

Sources

  • U.S. EPA, Emission Factors for Greenhouse Gas Inventories (GHG Emission Factors Hub), Table 1: natural gas 1 026 Btu/scf and 53.06 kg CO₂/MMBtu; distillate fuel oil No. 2 0.138 MMBtu/gal and 73.96 kg CO₂/MMBtu
  • EN 14825:2022 Air conditioners, liquid chilling packages and heat pumps — Testing and rating at part load conditions and calculation of seasonal performance (SCOP)
  • U.S. DOE, 10 CFR Part 430 Subpart B Appendix N (AFUE of furnaces and boilers, higher heating value basis)

Cite this calculator

Papandreou, C. (2026). Heat pump vs gas boiler running cost calculator. Engineering Bible. https://engineeringbible.com/energy/heat-pump-cost/

Embed this calculator on your site

Copy this HTML into your page. The calculator stays free to use and links back here.

By Christos Papandreou. Updated . How the numbers are checked.